Last night I had a date with old high school friends
I didn't know that he'd come along with them
And oh my God, he is still so hot and all grown up
He started reminiscing, I didn't catch a thing
The music was too loud and the wine kicked in
Couldn't help but think I'm too old for this
But I won't admit it, oh

He pulled me closer just to say
I'm the one that got away
So I slowly grabbed his face

We should've danced when I was seventeen
We should've slept when I still cared about dreams
We could've been together, happily ever after
Just like in my teenage fantasies
We should've danced when I was seventeen
Now here we are in 2023
We could've been forever, but you fucking never
Gave me any teenage memories
Now you're too late
Now you're too late (too late)

Back then I was below him, even I could tell
But now he wants a piece 'cause I'm doing well
His long lost friends with their [?] are now my fans, oh

He tried to catch me in his arms
Told me I'm the girl he wants
So I slowly broke his heart

We should've danced when I was seventeen
We should've slept when I still cared about dreams
We could've been together, happily ever after
Just like in my teenage fantasies
We should've danced when I was seventeen
Now here we are in 2023
We could've been forever, but you fucking never
Gave me any teenage memories
Now you're too late
Now you're too late
Now you're too late

I got older, I got wiser
Though I miss those good old times
Where I'd never wonder what it's like to [?] again
We should've danced when I was seventeen
We should've slept when I still cared about dreams
We could've been forever, but you fucking never
Gave me any teenage memories
Now you're too late